Pitcher A vs. Pitcher B
Pitcher A: 254-186, 3,824 innings, 2,478 strikeouts, 1,390 walks, 105 ERA+ (the league-adjusted ERA stat, where 100 is league average)
Pitcher B: 258-195, 3,908 and 2/3 innings, 2,342 strikeouts, 1,117 walks, 105 ERA+
Who do you put into the Hall of Fame? Both of them? Neither of them?
Pitcher A is Jack Morris.
Pitcher B is Jamie Moyer.
Think on that.